When you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, DreamSlumber earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
Choosing an organic mattress is a big deal. You want it to be safe. You want it to be comfy. And you want it to last.
The two top choices are My Green Mattress and Naturepedic. Both brands offer non-toxic mattresses. Both are GOTS-certified. And both focus on your health and comfort.
But which one is better for your sleep needs?
That’s what this guide will help you figure out. We’ll break down all the facts. We’ll look at features like firmness, feel, edge support, and pain relief. We’ll also discuss trial periods, returns, and pricing.
So, whether you want the best organic mattress for couples, need motion isolation, or are curious about My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic for back pain, we’ve got you covered.
By the end, you’ll know which mattress is right for you and your body.
Let’s get started with a quick side-by-side look at both mattresses.
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic
| Feature | Naturepedic EOS Classic | My Green Mattress Natural Escape |
| Price (Queen) | Check Latest Price | Check Latest Price |
| Firmness Options | Customizable on both sides | Medium-firm (7.5) |
| Thickness | Around 12 inches | Around 11 inches |
| Trial Period | 100 nights | 365 nights |
| Warranty | 25 years | 20 years |
| Best For | Couples, sensitive sleepers, custom comfort | All sleep styles, couples, and back pain |
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: Top Similarities
These two mattresses may come from different brands. However, they share many similarities. Let’s explore the main things they both offer.
- Certified Organic and Non-Toxic: Both mattresses are made with 100% certified organic materials. They both meet top certifications like Global Organic Textile Standards (GOTS) and GOLS.
- Supportive Coil Systems: Both brands offer zoned support. That means more support where your body needs it. Each mattress uses a pocketed coil system for strong support and comfort.
- Pressure Relief and Comfort: Each mattress has a 3-inch layer of organic latex. Latex is great for pressure relief, especially on the shoulders and hips.
- Cooling and Breathable Properties: These mattresses are made with natural materials that let air flow through. Organic wool and cotton help draw heat away from your body.
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: Top Differences
While these mattresses share many great features, there are also some key differences. Let’s look at what sets them apart.
- Customization: Naturepedic offers full-layer customization. Meanwhile, My Green Mattress does not provide this level of customization. It comes in just one firm feel.
- Edge Support: My Green Mattress has strong edge support, thanks to its 7-zone coil system. Naturepedic has edge support, too, but it’s slightly softer around the edges.
- Trial Flexibility: My Green Mattress offers a 365-night trial. Naturepedic gives you 100 nights but lets you swap layers for free within that time.
- Value Proposition: My Green Mattress costs less. The queen size is around $1,499. Naturepedic EOS Classic costs around $2,799 for a queen.
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: Construction & Feel Differences
What’s the Firmness Difference?
You can choose your firmness level with Naturepedic. It offers multiple options: firm, medium, or plush. You can even customize each side of the bed. This makes it great for couples with different firmness needs.
In contrast, My Green Mattress comes in one firmness feel, medium-firm (about 7.5 out of 10). It’s firm enough for support yet still comfy for pressure relief. It’s ideal for back, side, and stomach sleepers.
What Does Each Mattress Feel Like?
The feel depends on the firmness layers you choose. If you prefer a cool, buoyant feel, latex offers gentle bounce and pressure relief. The customizable comfort makes it feel “just right” for many sleepers.
In comparison, My Green Mattress has a naturally buoyant feel with a responsive latex top. The 7-zone coils offer solid support in the lower back. It feels slightly firmer than average but still cozy. The hand-tufted top adds some softness without being too plush.
How Does The Construction Differ?
| Layer | Naturepedic EOS Classic | My Green Natural Escape |
| Comfort Layer | 3” Organic latex + PLA comfort | 3” GOLS-certified Dunlop latex |
| Transition Layer | Optional: Customize or replace | No separate layer |
| Support Core | 8” Encased coils with edge support | Up to 1,462 pocketed coils with zoned lumbar support |
| Cover | Organic cotton + wool batting | Organic cotton + organic wool |
| Other Materials | Organic PLA + cotton encasement | No glues, button tufted (no adhesives) |
| Build Style | Modular, customizable layers | One-piece, hand-tufted structure |
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic Per Body Type
Your body weight and sleep position matter when choosing a mattress. Let’s see how Naturepedic and My Green Mattress perform for side, back, and stomach sleepers across different body types.
Naturepedic Mattress
| Body Weight | Side Sleepers | Back Sleepers | Stomach Sleepers |
| Under 130 lbs | Good | Excellent | Fair |
| 130–230 lbs | Excellent | Excellent | Good |
| Over 230 lbs | Good | Good | Fair |
My Green Mattress
| Body Weight | Side Sleepers | Back Sleepers | Stomach Sleepers |
| Under 130 lbs | Fair | Good | Excellent |
| 130–230 lbs | Good | Excellent | Good |
| Over 230 lbs | Fair | Good | Fair |
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: Comparing Mattress Performance
Both Naturepedic and My Green Mattress are built with care. They use safe, organic materials and quality support systems. But how do they perform night after night? Let’s look at the key features that matter most to sleepers.
Temperature
Both Naturepedic and My Green Mattress do a great job of keeping you cool at night. They use organic cotton, wool, and latex, which are naturally breathable. These materials let air flow freely and pull heat away from your skin. This helps you sleep without feeling hot or sweaty.
Naturepedic includes organic wool in the quilted cover, which helps wick away moisture. The latex layer underneath doesn’t trap body heat like foam. It stays cool to the touch and lets your body breathe. The coil system at the bottom adds airflow and keeps the mattress from holding heat.
My Green Mattress also keeps things cool with similar materials. It uses GOTS-certified organic wool and cotton, which feel soft and fresh. The Dunlop latex layer doesn’t hold onto heat and adds firmness without overheating. Its 7-zone coil system improves airflow all over the mattress.
If you’re a hot sleeper, you’ll be happy with either one. But Naturepedic may feel slightly cooler due to the customizable firmness, which allows more airflow if you pick firmer settings.
Motion Isolation
Motion isolation is important for couples. It helps reduce sleep disruptions if one person tosses or turns. Both mattresses use pocketed coils and latex, but they handle motion in slightly different ways.
Naturepedic has good motion control, especially if you choose a medium or firm feel. The coils are wrapped individually, which means they don’t all move at once. The latex comfort layer has some bounce, but not as much as memory foam. You may feel small movements, but nothing too jarring. Plus, you can choose different firmness levels on each side, which helps when two people have different sleep needs.
My Green Mattress performs even better when it comes to motion isolation. Its hand-tufted build holds layers in place more tightly. The zoned coil system absorbs more motion around the lumbar area and edges. While it still has some natural bounce from latex, it does a great job of limiting partner disturbance.
If you’re a very light sleeper, My Green Mattress may offer more peace through the night. But both are solid choices for couples.
Edge Support
Both mattresses have good edge support, but My Green Mattress has the upper hand.
Naturepedic has decent edge support thanks to its 8-inch coil layer. The outer rows of coils are firmer to give more strength along the edge. This makes sitting or lying near the side feel stable. However, if you choose a softer comfort layer, the edge may sink a little. Firmer layers provide better support around the border.
My Green Mattress offers stronger and more consistent edge support. Its 7-zone coil system includes reinforced coils around the perimeter. These help the edges stay upright and prevent sagging over time. Whether you’re sitting or sleeping near the side, it feels steady and secure.
If you need to use every inch of your mattress or just like sitting on the side, My Green Mattress has a stronger edge. But Naturepedic still performs well, especially in firmer setups.
Pressure Relief
Pressure relief is important if you sleep on your side or deal with joint pain. You want a mattress that cushions your shoulders, hips, and knees without causing tension.
Naturepedic does a great job of relieving pressure. It uses a 3-inch organic latex comfort layer that’s soft but responsive. The latex hugs your body and spreads out your weight, which helps reduce strain on pressure points. The best part? You can change the comfort layer if it doesn’t feel right. That’s great if you’re trying to find the perfect feel for your body shape and sleeping style.
My Green Mattress also offers strong pressure relief, especially for heavier sleepers. Its Dunlop latex feels firmer and more supportive than Talalay latex. That means it’s not as soft, but it still cushions your body well. The 7-zone coil system also helps by adding extra softness where your body needs it most, like your shoulders and hips.
For lightweight or side sleepers, Naturepedic’s softer options may feel more comforting. For average or heavy sleepers, My Green Mattress offers firm and steady support that still reduces pressure.
Pain Relief
Pain relief often depends on how well a mattress supports your body. You want a mattress that keeps your spine in line and reduces pressure without sagging.
Naturepedic is one of the best organic mattresses for pain relief. Its customizable design means you can adjust the comfort and support layers until your pain goes away. If your back hurts, you can choose firmer latex. If your shoulders ache, you can go softer. You can also change one side without affecting the other, which helps couples with different pain needs.
My Green Mattress offers excellent support for back and stomach sleepers. The 7-zone lumbar coils are firmer in the middle, where your lower back needs it most. That helps keep your spine in the right shape. The firm feel also prevents your hips from sinking too deep, which is key for pain relief. However, if you’re a side sleeper with joint pain, you might need a mattress topper for extra cushioning.
In short, Naturepedic wins for customizable pain relief. My Green Mattress works better if you prefer strong, steady lumbar support out of the box.
Durability
Both mattresses are designed to last many years. They use high-quality organic materials and smart construction to stay supportive over time.
Naturepedic has a big advantage here because of its modular design. You can unzip the mattress and replace or swap layers whenever needed. If one layer wears out, you don’t need a whole new bed. That saves money and reduces waste. The materials, like organic latex and cotton, are long-lasting and strong.
My Green Mattress is also built to last. It’s handcrafted and button-tufted, which keeps everything in place. The coil system supports up to 750 pounds. The latex is durable and resists sagging. Plus, the mattress keeps its shape better than many all-foam models.
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: Company Policies
Naturepedic Policies
- Trial: You get a 100-night sleep trial. You can return it for free if you’re not happy.
- Layer Swaps: You can swap layers for free within the first 100 days. This helps you find your perfect feel without returning the whole mattress.
- Warranty: Naturepedic gives a long 25-year limited warranty. This covers major defects over time.
- Shipping: Free shipping across the USA.
- Returns: Returns are easy and also free within the trial period.
My Green Mattress Policies
- Trial: You get a longer 365-night trial. That’s a full year to test it.
- Layer Swaps: No layer-swapping options. You must return the whole mattress if it doesn’t feel right.
- Warranty: Comes with a 20-year limited warranty. It covers most issues and signs of sagging.
- Shipping: Free shipping across the USA.
- Returns: Returns are free within the trial period. No extra charges or restocking fees.
Comparing My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic Price
| Size | Naturepedic EOS Classic | My Green Natural Escape | Savings |
| Twin | $2,199 | $999 | Save $1,200 |
| Full | $2,599 | $1,199 | Save $1,400 |
| Queen | $2,799 | $1,499 | Save $1,300 |
| King | $3,199 | $1,799 | Save $1,400 |
My Green Mattress vs Naturepedic: 7 Frequently Asked Questions
Which has better edge support?
Both mattresses offer good edge support. But My Green Mattress performs slightly better in this area. It uses a 7-zone coil system with strong edges. This helps you sit or sleep near the edge without feeling like you’re slipping. Naturepedic also has edge support, but it’s not as firm or reinforced as My Green.
Can I adjust firmness after purchase?
Yes, with Naturepedic, you can. The EOS Classic lets you swap layers for free during the first 100 days. You can also buy new layers later if your comfort needs change. My Green Mattress does not offer firmness adjustments. If it feels too soft or too firm, you must return the entire mattress.
Which isolates motion better for couples?
Naturepedic and My Green Mattress both do well at motion isolation. But Naturepedic performs a bit better, especially with the latex and coil layers working together. This is helpful for couples who move a lot during sleep. You won’t feel much motion from your partner turning or getting in and out of bed.
Are these mattresses good for back pain?
Yes, both are excellent for back pain. They offer firm support and pressure relief. Naturepedic is great because you can adjust layers to fit your body. My Green Mattress uses a zoned coil system that supports the lower back. Both mattresses keep your spine aligned, which can reduce pain and stiffness.
Which brand has a longer trial period?
My Green Mattress offers a longer trial. You get 365 nights to test it at home. That’s a full year. Naturepedic offers a 100-night trial, which is still good but shorter. If you want more time to decide, My Green gives you better peace of mind with its full-year trial period.
Do they sleep cool?
Yes, both mattresses sleep cool. They use breathable organic cotton and wool, which helps reduce heat. My Green Mattress may feel slightly cooler for some people because of its zoned coils and airflow design. But both beds work well for hot sleepers.
Which is better for heavy sleepers?
Both are strong choices, but My Green Mattress might be better for heavier sleepers. It supports up to 750 pounds and has strong coils and edge support. Naturepedic is still a good option, especially if you want to adjust layers. But My Green offers more lift and firmness right out of the box.
Final Take
Here’s a quick guide to help you choose between these two organic mattresses:
Naturepedic EOS Classic
Pros
- Fully customizable firmness layers, even years later
- 100-night trial with unlimited layer swaps within that time
- Made from 100% GOTS-certified organic materials, no adhesives
- 25-year warranty and modular design improve longevity
Cons
- Higher price point
- Slightly softer edges unless you select firmer layers
Best for: Couples or individuals who want full comfort control. Ideal for back pain relief and customization.
My Green Mattress Natural Escape
Pros
- More affordable price for a high-end organic mattress
- Medium-firm feel supported by a 7-zone coil system
- Excellent edge support and motion isolation
- 365-night trial and strong 20-year warranty
Cons
- No ability to adjust firmness post-purchase
- A slightly firmer feel may be too rigid for some side sleepers
- Manual returns are required if you want a different feel
Best for: Shoppers seeking a budget-friendly, durable, and firm organic mattress. Great for back and stomach sleepers. Pair it with an organic mattress protector to extend its lifespan.
