When you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, DreamSlumber earns from qualifying purchases. Learn more.
⭐ Quick Verdict: Plush vs Pillow Top Mattress
Plush Mattress is best if you want soft, pressure-relieving comfort that gently hugs the body, making it ideal for side sleepers and people who like a “sink-in” feel.
Pillow Top Mattress is better if you prefer a plush surface with added cushioning
- Best for Side Sleepers & Pressure Relief → Plush
- Best for Back Sleepers & Balanced Support → Pillow Top
- Best for Luxury Feel & Extra Cushion → Pillow Top
Keep reading for a full breakdown of comfort, durability, and which type suits different sleep styles.
Buying your first mattress can feel overwhelming. There are just too many choices in the mattress market today. You see terms like plush, pillow top, or Euro top everywhere. But what do they mean?
If you like soft comfort, you’ll often hear about plush and pillow-top options. But these two terms are not the same. Different mattresses feel different. Some are softer. Some are deeper. Some offer better edge support or cooling features.
Mattress marketing often mixes these terms. So you may feel lost in the details. But don’t worry. In this guide, we’ll help you choose the right mattress wisely.
We’ll walk you through every detail. By the end, you’ll know the difference between plush and pillow-top mattress feel.
Whether you’re a back sleeper, a side sleeper, or move a lot, we’ll help you decide. Let’s start this Plush vs Pillow Top Mattress journey together.
What Exactly Is a Plush vs. Pillow Top Mattress?
As we said, when shopping for a soft mattress, you’ll often hear words like plush, pillow top, or Euro top. They may sound similar, but they don’t mean the same thing. Let’s break them down one by one first.
What Is a Plush Mattress?
The word “plush” can have different meanings in mattress talk. First, it refers to the firmness levels scale. Plush means soft, softer than medium. It feels gentle, cushiony, and comforting like a soft cloud under your back or hips. Second, it can describe the construction style of the mattress surface.
In this case, a plush mattress means it has extra padding sewn into the top. The top looks smooth and flat. It’s not puffy like a pillow top. But it still feels soft and cozy under your body.
Some plush mattresses come with a tight top finish. Others use memory foam or even natural latex, known for its supportive yet contouring distinctive feel of a latex mattress that balances softness and resilience. They don’t all feel the same. So always check what materials are used inside.
Plush tops are a favorite for side sleepers who want pressure relief and soft comfort. They’re also a nice pick for college students or guest rooms needing affordable softness.
What Is a Pillow Top Mattress?
A pillow top mattress has a thick pillow top layer stitched onto the top surface. It looks like a big cushion placed right on top of the mattress. It’s made to give an extra soft feel, especially in the upper comfort layer.
This additional layer often uses soft materials like:
- Memory foam comfort layer
- Natural latex foam
- Cotton or fiberfill
- Or cooling gel foam
This top layer is clearly separate from the mattress base. You can actually see the stitching line where the pillow top starts.
The goal is deep comfort and more pressure relief, without changing the support below. That’s why many people love pillow tops for their hips, shoulders, and joints. Some people call these “cloud beds” because of how pillowy they feel.
But some pillow tops may sag over time, especially if made from cheap materials. Choosing a good brand, backed by thorough top mattress brand comparisons, and rotating your new mattress can help prevent this.
What Is a Euro Top Mattress?
A Euro top is similar to a pillow top, but with a more finished look. Instead of being sewn on top, the extra layer is stitched inside the edges. This makes the surface look more even and neat.
Euro tops still feel soft and plush. But they often feel a bit firmer than pillow tops. Because the layers are packed tightly. There’s less space to squish.
Euro tops may also last longer. They tend to resist mattress sagging better over time. These are often found in hybrid mattress construction with:
- Individually wrapped coils for support
- Foam or latex for comfort
- And a sleek, flat top look
People who want plush comfort, but also clean lines, often pick Euro tops. They’re great for motion isolation for couples and side sleepers, too.
Plush vs. Pillow Top: A Head-to-Head Comparison
Now that you know the basics, let’s break things down even more. Each type—Plush Top, Pillow Top, and Euro Top—has its own feel and build.
To help you decide, we’ve made a comparison table. It shows the most important differences, so you can pick what feels right for your body’s shape.
| Feature | Plush Top | Pillow Top | Euro Top |
| Top Layer Design | Sewn flat with extra padding | Separate, visible cushion layer sits atop | Extra layer sewn underneath the outer cover |
| Feel | Soft, cushioned feel, more even surface | Extra softness, fluffy, deep sinking feel | Soft but slightly firmer than a pillow top |
| Common Materials | Memory foam, latex, or soft polyfoam | Memory foam, cotton, gel foam, or fiberfill | High-density foam, latex, or fiberfill |
| Firmness Range | Soft (4–5 on firmness scale) | Very soft (3–4 on firmness scale) | Soft-medium (4–6 on firmness scale) |
| Support Base | Foam or innerspring | Mostly innerspring or hybrid | Hybrid or advanced innerspring |
| Pressure Relief | Good | Excellent | Excellent with better weight distribution |
| Motion Isolation | Moderate to good | Very good for couples | Great for motion control |
| Edge Support | Fair to good | Can be weak if not reinforced | Better edge support due to dense structure |
| Mattress durability | Moderate | Lower if cheap materials are used | Higher durability, layers hold shape better |
| Best For | Side sleepers, light sleepers, and guest beds | Side sleepers, couples, and plush lovers | Combo sleepers, back sleepers, and heavier people |
| Price Range | $297-$649 | $329-$657 | $376-$388 |
| Looks | Flat and simple | Puffy, visible cushion top | Clean, modern, smooth appearance |
| Product Example | LUCID 14 Inch Memory Foam Mattress | Suiforlun Pillow Top Memory Foam Hybrid 12″ | Zinus Eurotop Spring Hybrid 12″ |
Which Mattress Is Best for YOUR Sleeping Position?
Your sleeping position plays a big role in choosing the right mattress top. What feels soft and cozy for one person might feel wrong for another.
Whether you sleep on your side, back, stomach, or all over, we’ve got you covered. Here’s how plush, pillow top, and Euro top mattresses perform for each style.
Side Sleepers
Side sleepers need a pressure relief mattress, especially for their shoulders and hips. A pillow top mattress is often the best choice. It cushions sharp pressure points gently.
Soft materials like memory foam or gel foam let your body sink just enough. A plush top or Euro top also works well if you want something softer but more stable.
Look for something rated around 4–5 on the mattress firmness scale. Avoid very firm beds. They can cause soreness in the sides and shoulders. For many, the best mattress for side sleepers is one that feels like a soft hug, but still provides enough support for the spine.
Back Sleepers
Back sleepers need spinal alignment above all. You want your hips to stay level. A Euro top is a great match here. It offers plushness plus good support underneath.
If you’re light or medium in weight, a plush top may work too. But avoid anything too soft. That may cause your lower back to sink too much. The ideal firmness for back sleepers is around 5–6 on the firmness scale.
Some people also enjoy memory foam comfort layers that cradle the spine naturally. Look for a hybrid mattress construction with zoned support or reinforced coils.
Stomach Sleepers
Stomach sleepers need firmness to keep the belly and chest from sinking too deeply. Too much softness can cause the spine to curve, leading to back pain.
So, a plush mattress may feel too soft, especially for heavier stomach sleepers. A firm mattress with a Euro top can be better if it includes strong innerspring coil support. Some tight top mattresses also work well for stomach sleepers.
If you sleep on your stomach, look for firmness around 6–7 on the scale. Need something softer? Try a plush vs pillow top for stomach sleepers test in a store.
Combination Sleepers
If you toss and turn at night with different sleeping positions, you need a bed that’s soft, but not too soft. A Euro top mattress is great for this unique combination. It balances comfort with bounce and provides support.
It also works well if you switch between side and stomach, and back sleepers. Avoid other beds that are too plush if you move a lot. You might sink in and get stuck.
Combination sleepers should aim for a medium firmness (around 5–6). Many hybrid mattresses with multiple layers of memory foam are great for this group.
Body Weight and Mattress Choice: A Crucial Factor
Now, let’s talk about how your body weight also plays a big role in mattress choice.
Your body weight affects how soft or firm a mattress feels. A mattress that feels plush to one person might feel too firm, or too soft, to another. That’s why it’s important to choose based on your weight, not just the mattress label.
Sleepers Under 130 lbs
If you’re on the lighter side, soft mattresses often feel much firmer to you. A pillow top mattress is often perfect here. It gives instant softness on the surface. The additional cushioning lets your shoulders and hips relax into the mattress with ease.
Plush top mattresses also work well, especially with memory foam comfort layers. But try to avoid extra firm beds or very dense foam types. They can feel like sleeping on wood.
For this group, comfort lives in the 3–5 range on the mattress firmness scale.
Sleepers 130–230 lbs
If you’re in this group, you have more mattress options. Most beds feel just as the brand describes—plush is plush, firm is firm.
Your weight gives you just enough pressure to activate the comfort layers. A plush top, Euro top, or pillow top can all work well. Focus more on your sleep style (side, back, combo) when choosing.
Still, check for support underneath. You’ll want a mattress that keeps your spine aligned. Hybrid mattress construction is a great choice here, especially for couples or combo sleepers.
Sleepers Over 230 lbs
Heavier sleepers need strong support first, then comfort on top. Too-soft beds may cause you to sink too far, leading to back pain and poor sleep. A soft pillow top may feel great at first, but could sag fast under pressure.
That’s why it’s important to choose a Euro top mattress or a firmer plush hybrid. So, you might look for:
- Strong innerspring coil support
- Latex or high-density foam
- And great edge support
Also, check the lifespan of a plush hybrid mattress before you buy. If you love soft comfort, pick a firm side with a plush Euro top.
And yes, if you’re wondering, is a pillow top mattress good for a heavy person? The answer is yes, if it’s reinforced and well-built.
Special Considerations: Back Pain, Couples, and Hot Sleepers
Some people have special needs when it comes to sleep. Maybe you have back pain. Or you share a bed with someone who moves a lot. Maybe you get hot at night and wake up sweaty.
Let’s see which type of mattress top is best for each of these needs.
Back Pain Relief
If you struggle with back pain, the wrong mattress can make it worse. Too soft, and your spine may sag. Too firm a side, and pressure builds up on your joints.
That’s why spinal alignment is key. You need a bed that supports your lower back. For severe pressure issues, specialized pressure-relieving mattresses offer advanced solutions beyond standard pillow tops. A Euro top mattress is often the best choice for this. It has enough support, plus the softer feel for comfort, but stays firm enough to hold your body straight.
A memory foam comfort layer can also help, as it molds to your spine’s natural curve. If you’re looking for the best pillow top mattress for back pain and side sleepers, choose one with:
- Strong hybrid construction
- Zoned support
- And medium firmness
Couples and Motion Transfer
Sharing a bed with a partner? Then you know how annoying motion transfer can be. Every time they roll over, you feel it. That can ruin a good night’s sleep.
A good mattress for couples should offer motion isolation. Pillow tops with memory foam do this very well. But do pillow-top mattresses reduce motion transfer? Many do, not all. Euro tops with dense materials can also help.
Stay away from spring-only beds. Those bounce too much unless they use pocketed coils. Also, look for strong edge support if you both need more room to spread out.
Hot Sleepers
Some people just sleep hot. They wake up sweaty and toss off the blanket every night. If that’s you, the wrong mattress can trap heat and make things worse.
Pillow tops with thick foam layers can sleep hot, unless they use cooling gel foam. Euro tops are usually cooler because the two layers are denser and more balanced. Also, natural latex mattresses breathe better and feel cooler to the skin.
If you’re a hot sleeper, look for:
- Cooling gel foam layers
- Breathable covers
- And the airflow channels in the base
Avoid basic memory foam unless it’s labeled as cooling or temperature-neutral.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is more durable, a plush or a Pillow Top mattress?
Euro tops are usually more durable than regular plush or pillow tops. Pillow tops can sag faster if made with low-quality materials. Always check what’s inside before you buy.
Can you flip a pillow-top mattress?
Most pillow-top mattresses are not flippable. They’re designed with a soft layer on top and support on the bottom. Flipping them may ruin the feel and support.
Is a pillow top or a plush mattress better for side sleepers with hip pain?
A pillow-top mattress is often best for side sleepers with hip pain. It gives more cushion around pressure points like the hips and shoulders. Just make sure it also supports your spine properly.
Do pillow-top mattresses sag over time?
Yes, they can sag, especially if the top layer is made from soft, cheap foam. To help prevent this, rotate the mattress regularly and choose one with high-quality support materials.
Is a Euro top better than a regular pillow top?
It depends on your sleep preferences. Euro tops are stitched inside the mattress for a cleaner look and better durability. They’re often a better choice for people who want both comfort and long-term support.
What’s the difference between a plush mattress and a memory foam mattress?
A plush mattress refers to how soft the surface feels. It could be made of various materials. A memory foam mattress uses special foam that molds to your body. Some memory foam beds are plush, but not all plush beds use memory foam.
Do I need special deep-pocket sheets for a pillow-top mattress?
Yes, you may need deep-pocket sheets if your pillow-top mattress is extra thick. Standard sheets may not fit well or might come off during the night.
Making Your Final Decision
The plush vs pillow top mattress debate isn’t just about softness. It’s about finding what supports your body and suits your sleep style. If you love deep cushioning and sleep on your firm side, a pillow top may feel just right. But if you prefer balanced comfort, better durability, and more support, a plush or Euro top might be the better fit.
Think about your sleeping position, body weight, and how your body feels each morning. The best mattress isn’t the softest one. It’s the one that helps you rest, heal, and wake up refreshed. In the end, your bed should feel like a retreat, a place to achieve personal preference for sleep products. Whether you choose plush or pillow top, let comfort and care guide you toward better sleep.
